We conducted a multilevel meta-analysis of 390 effect sizes from 167 studies with 157,923 participants examining the relationship between connectedness with lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer/questioning (LGBTQ+) communities and health-related outcomes, following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. We conducted our initial search in January 2023 in APA PsycInfo, ERIC, Medline, and Open Dissertations, selecting studies that (a) measured LGBTQ+ community connectedness, (b) measured health, and (c) provided an estimate of the relationship between LGBTQ+ community connectedness and health. We found that connectedness with LGBTQ+ communities promotes mental health (r = .11), well-being (r = .17), and physical health (r = .09). Conversely, we found that connectedness with LGBTQ+ communities promotes substance use among younger participants, likely through behavioral engagement with LGBTQ+ others. We found that connectedness with LGBTQ+ communities was related to less mental health and more suicidality for younger people, likely because younger LGBTQ+ people seek out connectedness in response to this psychological distress. We also found that connectedness was not as health-promoting for LGBTQ+ individuals with multiple marginalized identities and that psychological feelings of belongingness with LGBTQ+ communities are generally more health-promoting than behavioral community engagement. Results from a narrative review and moderation meta-analyses suggested that, contrary to predictions made by minority stress theory, connectedness with LGBTQ+ communities does not buffer the relationship between minority stressors and health. Rather, meta-analytic mediation analyses suggested that proximal minority stressors negatively impact health-related outcomes by reducing connectedness with LGBTQ+ communities and that distal minority stressors are often less impactful on health-related outcomes because they promote connectedness with LGBTQ+ communities. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
Meta-Analysis Psychological bulletin. 2024 Nov;150(11):1261-1286. doi: 10.1037/bul0000447 Q119.82025
When connecting with LGBTQ+ communities helps and why it does: A meta-analysis of the relationship between connectedness and health-related outcomes
当与LGBTQ+社区建立联系有帮助时及其原因:关于联系性与健康相关结果之间关系的元分析 翻译改进
作者单位 +展开
作者单位
DOI: 10.1037/bul0000447 PMID: 39480291
摘要 中英对照阅读
Keywords:LGBTQ+; community connectedness; health outcomes
我们进行了一项多层次的元分析,研究了来自167项研究的390个效应量和157,923名参与者之间的联系,这些研究探讨了与同性恋、异性恋、双性恋、跨性别者及酷儿/疑问身份(LGBTQ+)社区的连接感与健康相关结果之间的关系。我们的研究遵循《系统评价和元分析首选报告项目》指南进行。我们在2023年1月在APA PsycInfo、ERIC、Medline和Open Dissertations数据库中进行了初始搜索,选择了符合以下标准的研究:(a) 测量了LGBTQ+社区连接感;(b) 测量了健康状况;以及(c) 提供了LGBTQ+社区连接感与健康之间关系的估计值。
我们发现,与LGBTQ+社区的联系促进了心理健康(r = .11)、幸福感(r = .17)和身体健康(r = .09)。相反,我们还发现,与LGBTQ+社区的联系会增加年轻参与者的物质使用,这可能是通过行为上与LGBTQ+群体互动实现的。此外,我们发现在较年轻的个体中,与LGBTQ+社区的联系较少导致心理健康问题和自杀倾向增加,原因很可能是年轻的LGBTQ+个体为了应对心理压力而寻求社交连接。
我们也发现,具有多重边缘化身份的LGBTQ+个体从中受益较小,并且对LGBTQ+社区的心理归属感比行为上的社群参与更能促进健康。叙事综述和调节元分析的结果表明,与少数群体压力理论的预测相反,与LGBTQ+社区的联系并不能缓解少数群体压力因素与健康之间的关系。反而,元分析中介效应分析显示,近期的少数群体压力因素通过减少与LGBTQ+社群的连接来负面影响健康相关结果,并且长期的少数群体压力因素往往对健康相关的结果影响较小,因为它们促进了与LGBTQ+社区的联系。(PsycInfo数据库记录 © 2024 APA, 所有权利保留)
相关内容
-
LGBTQ+ Engagement in Activism: An Examination of Internalized Heterosexism and LGBTQ+ Community Connectedness
LGBTQ+群体的政治参与:内部化的异性霸权观和LGBTQ+社群联系感的考察
Journal of homosexuality. 2022 Apr 16;69(5):911-924.
-
Age Moderates the Association of Community Connectedness and Psychological Distress Among LGBTQ+ Youth and Adults
社区归属感与LGBTQ+青少年和成年人心理困扰之间的关系受到年龄的影响
Journal of homosexuality. 2024 Feb 23;71(3):722-740.
-
Does LGBTQ+ Community Connectedness Buffer Discrimination's Indirect Effect on Generalized Anxiety Through Rejection Sensitivity in LGBTQ+ U.S. Adults?
LGBTQ+社群联系能否缓解歧视通过拒绝敏感度对美国成人LGBTQ+的间接影响?
Journal of homosexuality. 2025 Apr 25:1-23.
-
Heightened vigilance and its associations with suicidal ideation and suicide attempt among 285 Korean transgender and nonbinary adults: Effect modification by connectedness to the LGBTQ+ community
高度警觉及其与285名韩国跨性别和非二元成年人自杀意念和自杀未遂之间的关联:LGBTQ+社区联系的修饰效应
Suicide & life-threatening behavior. 2024 Jun 18.
-
Families of Choice and Community Connectedness: A Brief Guide to the Social Strengths of LGBTQ Older Adults
LGBTQ老年群体的社会优势简述:有关选择家庭和社区联系的论述
Journal of gerontological nursing. 2020 Feb 1;46(2):5-8.
-
The “evidence” is in! It does get better!
证据已出!彩虹过后必有希望!
Diabetes care. 2015 Jan;38(1):3-5.
-
The impact of stigma on the LGBTQ patient care experience and health outcomes in the United States
美国性取向和性别身份认同污名化对医疗保健体验及健康结果的影响
Anthropology & medicine. 2024 Dec 5:1-6.
-
A randomized trial of acceptance-based behavioral therapy to improve mental health outcomes for LGBTQ+ persons: Study protocol
基于接受的行为疗法改善LGBTQ+人群心理健康结果的随机试验:研究方案
Contemporary clinical trials. 2023 Jul:130:107211.